In the search stage
That list looks different everywhere. At Google it is a row of search results, on a rental website an overview page, on a booking platform a tile view. The question is the same everywhere: which tile is worth a click and which is not.
A grey sky, a poor crop, a house half-hidden behind shrubs or a backlit interior shot disappears from such a list at once. Not because visitors consciously weigh those things, but because a tile placed next to professional photos simply attracts less attention. Photos also appear beyond the website itself: in Google results, in shared links, in preview cards on social media. What does not work in a tile does not work there either.